Paediatric Resuscitation Readiness Through the Participants’ Eyes: Perceptions of Announced and Unannounced In-Situ Simulations

Background. Simulation-based training is essential for maintaining paediatric resuscitation competence, yet the optimal way to organise in-situ simulation remains debated. Announced simulations allow preparation and easier scheduling, while unannounced simulations may better reflect routine working conditions. Beyond technical performance, participants’ subjective experience is also important, as stress, perceived preparedness and educational value may influence engagement with recurrent simulation programmes. Understanding these perceptions may therefore help shape sustainable, continuous resuscitation education.

Objective. To compare participants’ perceptions of announced and unannounced in-situ paediatric resuscitation simulations, with emphasis on stress, preparedness, teamwork, communication, learning value and debriefing.

Methods. We conducted a prospective observational study at the University Children’s Hospital Ljubljana between September 2023 and May 2024. The simulation programme included 24 in-situ paediatric resuscitation simulations, with each of 12 departments completing one announced and one unannounced simulation. After each session, participants completed an anonymous questionnaire based primarily on a 5-point Likert scale (1 = strongly agree, 5 = strongly disagree). Section 1 evaluated the just-completed simulation, including stress, preparedness, teamwork, communication, leadership, disruption of work, usefulness of debriefing and perceived benefit for clinical practice. Section 2 was completed only by participants who had previously experienced both formats and explored comparative perceptions of announced versus unannounced simulations. Descriptive statistics were used throughout. Responses following announced and unannounced simulations in Section 1 were compared using the Mann–Whitney U test. Comparative responses in Section 2 were analysed using bootstrap estimation.

Results. The study included 159 valid responses: 93 (58.5%) following announced and 66 (41.5%) following unannounced simulations. Unannounced simulations were perceived as more stressful than announced simulations (median 2.5 vs. 3.0, p<0.001), and participants reported feeling less prepared (median 3.0 vs. 4.0, p<0.001). Despite these differences, both formats received highly positive ratings for educationally relevant aspects. Simulation-based learning and teamwork were rated highly in both groups (median 1.0 for both), as were the usefulness of debriefing and perceived improvement in clinical practice (median 1.0 for both).

Among participants familiar with both formats, respondents clearly perceived a difference between announced and unannounced simulations, with strong disagreement with the statement that there was no difference (median 4.0, 95% CI 4.0–5.0). Unannounced simulations were perceived as more stressful (median 2.0, 95% CI 1.0–2.0) and were moderately perceived as more disruptive to routine work (median 3.0, 95% CI 2.0–3.0). Comparative responses suggested better concentration, performance and collaboration during announced simulations (median 3.0, 95% CI 2.0–3.0 for each). Perceived learning value was broadly comparable, with no clear preference for either format regarding learning benefit.

Conclusions. Announced and unannounced simulations generated distinct participant experiences, particularly regarding stress and preparedness, while both were perceived as highly valuable educational interventions. Unannounced simulations were more stressful and associated with lower perceived preparedness. Both formats were highly valued for learning, teamwork, debriefing and perceived improvement in clinical practice. Participant experience should therefore be considered when designing longitudinal in-situ resuscitation programmes, with both formats potentially serving complementary educational purposes.