A Comparison of Head Injury Management Pre and Post Adoption of PECARN Rules

Background: Head injuries constitute 6% of paediatric emergency department (ED) attendances, yet the majority are minor injuries and do not require imaging. Although CT is an important investigation for identifying intracranial pathology, radiation exposure may outweigh the benefit. The implementation of Paediatric Emergency Care Applied Research Network (PECARN) guidelines aims to identify children who are at risk of significant traumatic brain injury while reducing unnecessary CT imaging. We aimed to compare the management of paediatric head injury presentations to Cork University Hospital (CUH) Paediatric ED in June 2019 and June 2026, focusing on the use of CT scan findings, following formal implementation of the PECARN guidelines at CUH.

Methods: A retrospective audit was performed in paediatric patients <16 years presenting to CUH paediatric ED with head injuries in June 2019 and June 2026. Data collected included age, sex, triage category, triage note, CT investigations and findings, and patient disposition. Patients with isolated facial or ocular injuries, non-traumatic neurological symptoms, or polytrauma not under the triage category “head injury” were excluded. The use of CT imaging was compared between these two periods.

Results: A total of 270 patients were included, 107 from June 2019 and 163 from June 2026. The 1-4year age group represented the majority of presentations in both years (54% in 2019 and 41% in 2026), with a male predominance (66% in 2019 and 58% in 2026). Falls were the most common mechanism of injury. The use of CT scans reduced from 10% (11 out of 107) in 2019 to 6% (10 out of 163) in 2026. In 2019 82% (9 out of 11) of CT scans were normal and 18% (2/11) had abnormal findings. Compared to 2026 where 40% (4 out of 10) were normal and 60% (6 out of 10) were abnormal. There was a low return rate for both 2019 (3 out of 107) and 2026 (4 out of 163). None of these patients had CT scans on return and were all discharged home. Lastly, the majority of patients in both 2019 and 2026 were discharged home (85% in 2019 and 92% in 2026), with few admissions. The reasoning behind admission is uncertain.

Conclusion: Head injury guidelines play an important role in reducing inappropriate CT imaging. PECARN is the guideline of choice at CUH due to its global recognition as well as high sensitivity and diversity. The findings of this audit suggest that the implementation of the PECARN guidelines after June 2019 has resulted in a 40% reduction in CT imaging. While at the same time improving detection of positive CT findings such as intracranial haemorrhages and skull fractures. The low rate of re-presentations and absence of CT scans done in return patients provides reassurance of PECARN guideline safety. No neurosurgical intervention was needed for any patients included in this audit however due to the exclusion of polytrauma patients, some of these patients may have been missed. Therefore, the exclusion of certain trauma groups should be considered when interpreting these findings.