Improving Access to Abdominal Ultrasound in Children Presenting with Abdominal Pain: A Longitudinal Quality Improvement Project

Background: Abdominal pain is a common presentation in paediatric admissions. Abdominal Ultrasound scan (USS) is the recommended initial imaging modality for suspected appendicitis; it is highly specific. Variation in imaging practice and access to USS, alongside variation of ultrasound reporting may limit its clinical utility. The 2022 Getting It Right First Time (GIRFT) report highlighted opportunities to improve care for paediatric patients presenting with abdominal pain. This quality improvement project evaluates the work of a district general hospital (DGH) to optimise the use of USS in children presenting with abdominal pain between 2022 and 2026.

Methods: This project was conducted in three separate PDSA cycles in a single DGH in which children referred to the general surgical team with abdominal pain were included over a specified time. Four interventions were implemented iteratively between 2022 and 2026: Increasing the number of sonographers trained in paediatric ultrasound, increasing the abdominal USS capacity for paediatric patients, developing a standardised ultrasound reporting checklist and establishing a dedicated daily abdominal USS slot for children presenting with abdominal pain, including weekends.

Results: 308 children presenting with abdominal pain across all three cycles were included in the analysis with a mean age of 12 years (range 3 -16 years) and a male to female ratio of 1:1.12.

Use of ultrasound in children who received imaging as the first line imaging modality increased from 30% in cycle one to 77% in cycle two and further to 90% in cycle three. In cycle one the most common alternative imaging was MRI (40%) which reduced to 13% in cycle 2 and to 0% in cycle three. Cycle two evaluated 80 cases of ultrasound which showed a specificity for acute appendicitis of 93.1% and sensitivity of 28.6%. Analysis of ultrasound reports compared to the standardised format found that only 5% commented on all markers of inflammation from the standardised reporting checklist in cycle one. By cycle three 50% of all reports mentioned all features. In cycle three 0% of patients required secondary imaging compared to 21% in cycle one.

Conclusion: Ultrasound is a powerful tool in assessment of children presenting with acute abdominal pain. This project demonstrates that improving access to dedicated ultrasound services, expanding the trained sonographer workforce and standardising reporting can improve the efficiency of the diagnostic pathway, reducing the need for secondary imaging. During the same time, a parallel audit at the trust has taken place which showed a decrease in negative Appendicectomy rate (NAR) from 14.1% to 6.4%, however due to the multifactorial nature, a direct causal relationship between increasing the use of ultrasound and the decrease in NAR is difficult to establish.