Evaluating Barriers to Ultrasound-Guided Vascular Access in Paediatric Departments

Background: Vascular access in paediatric patients is frequently challenging, often requiring repeated attempts, which are associated with distress for patients, parents and staff. Infrared ‘cold light’ transillumination is a well-established practice that requires minimal training, although a systematic review of evidence shows its use provides no significant improvement in first-time success. There is an international evidence-based consensus in adult medicine that ultrasound (US) best facilitates successful cannulation. Similarly, growing evidence suggests that US use in paediatric peripheral vascular access also improves first-time success. Nevertheless, this study identifies low uptake of US-guided vascular access by clinical staff in Mid-Yorkshire, UK. To investigate this further, the AcCESS US (Acquiring Clinical Experience and Starter Skills in Ultrasound) project identifies barriers to US use and designs targeted interventions to address them.

Methods: A Google Forms survey was designed to generate qualitative data in line with the research goals. This survey was distributed to paediatric medical staff (consultants, resident doctors and nurses) via email and placing posters publicising the project in high-traffic areas (e.g., staff rooms, treatment rooms and handover rooms). Using a Likert scale, the survey gauged the respondents' perceived utility of US use in vascular access, assessed the frequency of their US use and assessed their confidence while using US. Perceived barriers to US use were reported in free-text boxes and data was amalgamated through thematic analysis. Collected metadata included job role and stage of training (as appropriate).

Results: There were 22 respondents, who were mainly paediatric speciality trainees. While 90% felt that US was useful in paediatric cannulation, only 27% felt confident using it. A lack of familiarity and/or training (71%) and difficulty accessing equipment (18%) were the main identified barriers, with 9% (mainly senior trainees) not using US due to confidence in unaided success.

Conclusion: Limited training opportunities are impacting confidence in evolving best practice. To address this lack of training/familiarity the author has designed and delivered a multistage targeted teaching intervention and is working to develop an ‘US culture’ supported by ‘US Champions’ (partly identified through this teaching intervention). The department will be resurveyed following the intervention to establish impact and the original benchmarking survey is being distributed more widely to identify how generalisable these barriers are, with a view to rolling out the designed intervention to improve regional practice.